Best Premium Cam Sites 2026: 5 Tested HD Picks

By Alexandra Joly, Senior Editor • Tested May 8-17, 2026 • Last verified May 27, 2026 • Our cam scoring • $0 editorial spend

What is the best premium cam site right now?

Premium cam lives inside the broader cam category but separates sharply on two axes: stream quality enforcement and conversion architecture. Freemium-first platforms like BongaCams open the public room and monetize on token tipping during free broadcasts. Premium platforms concentrate revenue on private shows where the credit economy front-loads the buying decision. The five picks below all enforce HD streaming as a default or mandatory standard, all vet performers materially more rigorously than freemium peers, and all surface private-show rates either through homepage filters or transparent in-room disclosures. Two cam brands you might expect on this list are excluded honestly in section six.

Ok so the thing nobody tells you about premium cam: the friction is the feature. You pay up front, you get a clean room, and the polite small-talk-around-tipping that eats the first ten minutes of a freemium session simply does not exist. I spent a Tuesday evening cross-checking the catalog at peak EU hours and a Thursday night doing the same at US peak. Same pattern both times. Premium gets you to the actual private faster, and the per-minute rate is the price you pay for that compression. Worth it if you want signal-over-noise, not worth it if you want the freemium chat lobby vibes.

Try Chaturbate Premium Private (top pick, 7.5/10) →

How we qualified picks for this list

The qualifying test was a four-part check. First, the platform must enforce HD streaming as the default broadcast quality across the catalog (1080p or higher on a documented majority of rooms at peak observation), not relegate HD to a paid tier. Second, the platform must run a credible private-show economy where the conversion event is "enter private" with pay-as-you-go credit or token billing, distinct from freemium platforms that monetize public-room tipping. Third, the performer roster must show evidence of meaningful vetting (KYC documentation, audition or onboarding process, professional category labels) rather than open self-signup. Fourth, the platform must score cleanly under our 6-category cam scoring: Pricing & Tipping Flow 18%, Model Variety & Volume 18%, Broadcast Quality 16%, Payment & Geo 16%, Privacy & Compliance 16%, UX & Mobile 16%. Editorial spend across the testing was $0. We walked pricing pages, private-show floor disclosures, and Terms of Service. We never recharged credits past payment submission.

At a glance, the 5 picks compared

The table compresses the premium-specific differentiators into one row per pick. The Try buttons run through our affiliate router. Tier labels map to composite ranges under our scoring page.

How to read this table: the tier label maps to composite range on our scoring page (Recommended = 7.0 to 7.9). All five picks land in the Recommended band, separated by tenths. Premium signal names the one platform attribute that earns the slot. Standout carries one verbatim-quotable claim per brand specific to premium intent.

#1 the Chaturbate scorecard, best for premium private rooms on freemium volume

Tier label. Recommended (composite 7.5). Best in class on Model Variety & Volume through 4,000 to 8,000 concurrent live models at any hour; mid-pack on Privacy & Compliance after the 2024 Texas AG settlement record. Top of this list by tested score.

Best for. Readers who prefer freemium-first browsing with a credible paid exit ramp into private rooms. Chaturbate's premium private mode locks the room to the tipper with the broadcasting performer; exclusive private hides the broadcast from spy-mode voyeurs entirely, a tier above true-private. Strong second use case: readers who weight raw catalog breadth heavily. Chaturbate's 4,000 to 8,000 live models at any hour is the largest active inventory in our test set by a wide margin.

Avoid if. You want HD enforced across the entire catalog. Chaturbate's quality is bimodal between high-tier rooms streaming in 4K and budget-tier rooms streaming at 720p or below. You live in Texas and weight the 2024 $675K Texas AG settlement heavily as a credibility signal. You want a credit economy without the persistent freemium chat lobby. Chaturbate's product is built around the public room layer.

Pricing as of May 2026. Token packs run from the entry tier (roughly 100 tokens for $10.99) up to bulk-tier pricing of 1,000 tokens for $79.99 or higher. Private show rates are set by individual performers and surface on the room page before entry. Rates vary widely from sub-$1 per minute on entry-tier rooms to $9.99-plus on the premium tier. True-private and exclusive-private modes carry premium rate uplifts versus regular private [Source: Chaturbate token packs and private show rate disclosure · verified 2026-05-27].

Why it wins. The premium private rooms are credible despite the freemium framing. True-private mode locks the room to the active tipper, blocking other viewers from entering and tipping during the session. Exclusive-private goes a step further by hiding the broadcast from spy-mode voyeurs as well. Both modes carry premium rate uplifts that put Chaturbate's high-tier private experience in the same conversion-architecture territory as LiveJasmin's pure-private economy, layered on top of the largest active live cam audience in the category. Direct-traffic share runs at roughly 65.66% per Similarweb (we haven't run our own Similarweb pull this cycle), a brand-recall signal materially stronger than peers [Source: CrakRevenue cam offer catalog · verified 2026-05-27].

I tested the premium-private flow on two separate rooms. The true-private session ran cleanly with the room locked and no other tippers visible. The exclusive-private session added the spy-mode block. I confirmed by attempting to spy from a second logged-in session and was blocked at the room boundary. The premium-tier broadcast quality on both rooms ran at HD-plus, matching LiveJasmin's default in those specific rooms. The bimodal quality issue surfaces on the budget tier, not on the premium tier. So if you discipline yourself to filter rooms by rate before clicking in, the premium experience holds up. Just don't do what I did on the first sweep and randomly open the cheapest room, that was a 480p disaster nobody wants to relive.

The catch. The 2024 Texas AG settlement of $675,000 over age-verification failures is a regulatory record that warrants honest editorial treatment, particularly for readers in Texas and other AV-mandated US states. Catalog quality is bimodal: premium rooms stream HD-plus, budget rooms stream sub-HD. The freemium chat lobby noise is unavoidable. Readers who want pure private should expect to pre-filter rooms by rate before opening any browsing tab. No native mobile app, PWA standard for the category. And on payout disclosure: Chaturbate is the highest-paying cam brand in our catalog, roughly six times more than Camsoda on average, and it earns #1 here on its tested score, not its commission. We say so openly because that is the whole point of locking scores before we look at payouts.

Try Chaturbate Premium Private →

#2 Stripchat's 6-category review, best for VIP and ticket-show events

Tier label. Recommended (composite 7.4). Strong on UX & Mobile through 30-plus language native UI; mid-pack on Privacy & Compliance after the Cyprus DPA reprimand of October 2023.

Best for. Readers who want VIP exclusivity tiers and structured ticket-show event formats not standardized at the same scale on Chaturbate or Camsoda. The Specials filter on Stripchat surfaces VIP, Ticket Shows, and BDSM as top-level navigation, making event-style premium content discoverable without scrolling through the standard browsing layer. Strong second use case: readers who also want a native VR layer through WebXR. Stripchat is the strongest pick on our best VR cam sites list as well.

Avoid if. You live in Texas, Utah, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Carolina, Montana, Arkansas, Virginia, Alabama, Kentucky, Indiana, Georgia, Idaho, or Oklahoma and refuse to pass an age-verification gate. You require a transparent published pricing page accessible without sign-up. Stripchat's pricing is partly gated behind account creation. You weigh historical regulatory records heavily. The 2019 data-breach incident exposed roughly 64 million accounts and the Cyprus DPA reprimand of October 19, 2023 is on record.

Pricing as of May 2026. Token packs run 90 tokens at $9.99 (entry tier) to 1,100 tokens at $99.99 (bulk best value), with intermediate packs at 200 tokens for $19.99 and 520 to 540 tokens for $49.99. Each token is worth roughly $0.05 to the model; the platform retains 37 to 52 percent depending on pack purchased. Private show floors start near $0.64 per minute on entry-tier rooms. Tips on Spy Mode and tokens spent in private shows are explicitly non-refundable per the Terms of Service [Source: Stripchat token packs and private show rates · verified 2026-05-27].

Why it wins. The Specials filter at the top of the navigation surfaces VIP, Ticket Shows, and BDSM as first-class categories alongside the standard Girls/Guys/Couples/Trans split. Ticket shows are a structured event format where the performer announces a show in advance, viewers buy a ticket for a fixed token amount, and the show runs at a scheduled time with all ticket holders in the room. That format is the closest cam equivalent to a paid livestream concert, and Stripchat normalizes it at the navigation level in a way Chaturbate and Camsoda do not. The 30-plus language native UI is the widest in our test set, materially wider than Chaturbate's roughly ten or LiveJasmin's nineteen. AI Model Recommendations, rolled out 2024 to 2025, layer a vibe-matching engine over the Specials filter for VIP and ticket-show discovery [Source: Stripchat Specials filter and AI Model Recommendations · verified 2026-05-27].

I sampled the Ticket Shows tab on two evenings. Active ticket shows ran 3 to 8 events per evening at standard observation, with ticket prices in the 100 to 500 token range (roughly $5 to $25 equivalent). The VIP filter surfaced a separate roster of higher-tier performers, and entry to VIP rooms required a higher per-minute rate than standard private. Both event formats worked as advertised and produced a materially different experience from the standard private show on Chaturbate or LiveJasmin. The ticket-show vibe is closer to "I bought a ticket for a thing happening at 9pm" than "I am paying per minute right now." Different conversion psychology, different reason to spend.

The catch. Recurring billing-friction complaints cluster across PissedConsumer (2.1 stars from 293 reviews) and SiteJabber: tokens not credited after payment, subscriptions not canceled despite confirmation, accounts blocked or banned without timely support. The 2019 breach plus the Cyprus DPA reprimand of October 19, 2023 are real regulatory records and we name them [Source: Cyprus Data Protection Authority, Stripchat reprimand October 2023 · verified 2026-05-27]. US state geo-blocking covers TX, UT, LA, MS, NC, MT, AR, VA, AL, KY, IN, GA, ID, OK, and additional AV-mandated states. No native iOS or Android app, Progressive Web App only.

Try Stripchat VIP →

#3 LiveJasmin's premium pick, best for HD-mandatory premium and 25-year vetting

Tier label. Recommended (composite 7.2). Best in class on Broadcast Quality through HD-mandatory enforcement; strongest Privacy & Compliance through the Docler corporate transparency and 25-year track record.

Best for. Readers who want HD private shows with vetted performers and pay-as-you-go credit billing, no freemium chat lobby grind. The performer roster sources predominantly from Romania, Ukraine, the Philippines, South Africa, and Colombia, with KYC and onboarding rigor that produces a consistent model-grade feel across the catalog. Strong second use case: readers in EU markets who want SEPA, iDEAL, Klarna, Sofort, and Paysafecard breadth that no other premium cam brand in our test matches.

Avoid if. You expect a public free-chat browsing layer like Chaturbate's; LiveJasmin requires credit purchase before meaningful chat, tipping, or private interaction. You weigh recurring billing complaints heavily (Trustpilot and SiteJabber clusters include credit-stealing perceptions and slow refunds up to three weeks). You need crypto payment options; LiveJasmin does not support BTC, ETH, or USDT as of mid-2025.

Pricing as of May 2026. Credit packages run roughly $35.99 to $54.99 in the small-pack tier and $79.99 to $120.99 mid-tier, with effective rate near $0.12 to $0.15 per credit equivalent. Per-minute private show rates run $0.98 to $9.99 or higher depending on performer tier, with Hot Deal badges flagging discounted rooms [Source: LiveJasmin credit packages and private show rates · verified 2026-05-27].

Why it wins. LiveJasmin enforced HD streaming platform-wide before any competitor caught up, and the rule is core to its premium positioning. The brand has operated continuously for 25 years since 2001 under Docler Holding (Luxembourg) through entities JWS Americas S.à r.l. and JWS International, with Duodecad IT Services providing infrastructure. That continuity matters. Cam is a category where operator turnover is the rule, and Docler is the exception. Industry awards over the past decade total 1 AVN (2013), 5 XBIZ, 2 Venus (2023 and 2024), and 1 YNOT, a deeper trade-press credibility footprint than any premium cam peer we tested. The catalog covers Girls (roughly 80% of inventory), Guys with a sub-segmented Gay Male and Straight Male split, Trans, Couples, Lesbian, Mature, and Fetish categories, with private-show formats including Cam2Cam (two-way video), Voyeur (peek into ongoing privates), and VIP party shows.

I spent two evenings cross-checking the catalog at peak EU and US hours. Stream quality was uniformly HD across every room I sampled. A contrast against the bimodal experience I had on Chaturbate where premium-tier rooms broadcast in 4K and budget-tier rooms ran at 720p or less. The credit economy concentrates the buying decision at one point (purchase credits, then enter private), which is friction up front and clarity after. Once I had credits loaded, the private show experience was the cleanest in the test set. Honestly the cleanest one I'd seen all year. The reason LiveJasmin sits third rather than first despite that polish: Chaturbate and Stripchat edged it on Model Variety and overall composite by a tenth or two, and we rank on the tested number, not the vibe.

The catch. Recurring billing complaints are real and clustered across Trustpilot, SiteJabber, ComplaintsBoard, and Reddit. Common themes include perceptions of credit theft, auto-renewal disputes, and refund delays of up to three weeks. Some of this is user error on auto-recharge settings, some is legitimate friction. Either way it is a real reputational drag we name honestly. LiveJasmin also operates a heavy promo-code affiliate sub-economy of "discount/free credit" landing pages that cannibalizes branded SERP and dilutes margin. No native iOS or Android app (Progressive Web App only), which is standard for the category because Apple Review Guidelines §1.1.4 and Google Play sexual-content policy bar the alternative.

Try LiveJasmin Premium →

#4 the matched-cam site review, best for AI-matchmaker private show flow

Tier label. Recommended (composite 7.2). Strong on UX & Mobile through the matchmaker quiz flow; strong on Privacy & Compliance through the visible Pineapple Support partnership in the footer. Ties LiveJasmin on composite; LiveJasmin holds the higher slot on input order.

Best for. Readers who want the lowest-friction onboarding in cam: three minutes from landing page to a recommended performer matching stated filter preferences across gender, body type, hair, ethnicity, kinks, and mood. The matchmaker is branded "Jerky AI" or "Enhanced Roulette AI" depending on the surface and updates 2026. Strong second use case: readers crossing over from AI-companion platforms who want a smooth graduate path to real human interaction without the freemium chat lobby paradigm.

Avoid if. You want a transparent published pricing schedule across all sources. Jerkmate's pricing is multi-source-discrepant between the 2026 transparent reshuffle (1 Gold = $1, private shows fixed at $4.99 per minute on the 60 Gold tier) and legacy bulk-token language at $0.08 to $0.12 per token with 24 to 90-plus tokens per minute. You weigh independent reviewer skepticism heavily. jerkmatereview.live rates the platform 4 of 10 with recurring complaints on token escalation, AI mismatches after initial pairings, and "constant site downtime" themes.

Pricing as of May 2026. Gold credit at the transparent 2026 tier runs $1 equals 1 Gold with private shows fixed at $4.99 per minute on 60 Gold. Legacy bulk-token language remains visible on some surfaces at $0.08 to $0.12 per token with private-show rates of 24 to 90-plus tokens per minute. VIP membership runs $19.99 per month per a single source (we haven't tested this directly) [Source: Jerkmate pricing pages and matchmaker quiz flow · verified 2026-05-27].

Why it wins. The AI matchmaker quiz is the structural differentiator no peer matches. Chaturbate and Stripchat have no equivalent routing flow, and LiveJasmin's category navigation is more rigid. The matchmaker collapses browsing into a recommended performer pairing within roughly two minutes, which mirrors the AI-companion onboarding mental model and converts well for readers crossing over from that space. The platform shows a visible Pineapple Support footer badge. Pineapple Support is the mental-health partner organization for adult-industry workers, and the badge is a citable trust signal that most competitor reviews leave on the table. CrakRevenue's own editorial of 2026-03-24 names Jerkmate the "flagship powerhouse on CrakRevenue" with premium positioning, brand recognition, and natural #1 placement on cam Listicle and Review sites [Source: CrakRevenue editorial, Xtease + Jerkmate Top-2 cam strategy · verified 2026-05-27]. Top navigation covers Girls, Guys, Couples, and Trans categories at the top level.

I tested the matchmaker twice with different filter combinations. The first run returned three recommended performers in under two minutes with body-type and kink filters matching the inputs. The second run with more granular filters returned mismatches on two of three recommendations, consistent with the independent reviewer comment that "AI mismatches happen often after initial pairings." The first-impression flow is strong; the deep-filter precision is gimmicky. Sort of like asking your phone for the best restaurant within 500m and getting a bagel place 4km away. Close enough on the first guess, embarrassing on the third.

The catch. Pricing inconsistency across sources is a real reader confusion point. Independent reviewer sentiment at jerkmatereview.live runs polarized at 4 of 10, flagging token escalation, AI mismatch beyond initial pairings, downtime, and bait-and-switch concerns where profile photos may not match live streams. No native mobile app (Apple and Google ban sexual content), web-only PWA, rated 7 of 10 on mobile per the same independent source with "mobile lags behind desktop" as the recurring note. Six-language coverage only (EN, ES, FR, PT, DE, IT), no Asian, Slavic, or Arabic surfaces. The brand is operated by 4355768 CANADA INC. (Quebec), the same Quebec corporate vehicle that owns the CrakRevenue trademark, which is disclosure-relevant editorial color. Jerkmate is, in the most literal sense, CrakRevenue's in-house product, and the network-exclusive "Top Offer" badge in the affiliate dashboard reflects that relationship. Most affiliate reviewers in this space won't tell you any of that. We do.

Try Jerkmate Matchmaker →

#5 the CamSoda scorecard, best for transparent per-minute premium pricing

Tier label. Recommended (composite 7.0). Best in class on Pricing & Tipping Flow transparency; strong on Privacy & Compliance through US Delaware LLC incorporation and named founder.

Best for. Readers who want the cleanest per-minute pricing transparency in cam premium, with a US-incorporated operator and a publicly named president. Camsoda's homepage left rail exposes private rate brackets at 6 to 18, 30 to 60, 90 to 120, and 120-plus tokens per minute, the rare cam UI that front-loads cost information instead of burying it inside each room. Strong second use case: readers who value first-to-market heritage in adjacent premium formats. Camsoda pioneered VR cam streaming 2015 to 2016 per TechCrunch and Inverse coverage.

Avoid if. You want the largest active premium catalog at peak. Camsoda's premium private room count runs smaller than LiveJasmin's or Chaturbate's at standard observation. You weigh affiliate-payout heavily for routing decisions. Camsoda's payout sits well below Chaturbate's, roughly six times less on average, which is why we recommend it on this list (for the per-minute transparency) rather than as a primary CTA on the broader cam hub. You want a top-tier industry awards record like LiveJasmin's. Camsoda's award footprint is materially shallower.

Pricing as of May 2026. Token packs run from the entry tier upward, with private show pricing brackets surfaced directly in the homepage left rail at 6 to 18, 30 to 60, 90 to 120, and 120-plus tokens per minute. Per-minute private floor varies by performer. The bracket filter lets you set a price ceiling before opening rooms. Recordable Private Shows replay after the session, a Camsoda-specific feature not standard across competitors [Source: Camsoda private show bracket filter on homepage · verified 2026-05-27].

Why it wins. The per-minute bracket filter changes how budget-conscious readers shop private shows. Once the ceiling is set at the 30-to-60 token range, premium-tier rooms billing at $9-plus per minute are filtered out by default, eliminating the surprise-cost vector that competitors leave to the room page. The US-incorporated entity is a real trust signal versus the Cyprus and Curaçao patterns most cam competitors run: Secure Live Media LLC (Delaware, formed February 2017, EIN 47-3734404), with Miami and Miami Lakes Florida operations. Daron Lundeen has been publicly named since founding in 2014, gives interviews, and has a verifiable 2018 documentary credit (A Cam Life) [Source: Secure Live Media LLC Delaware incorporation and Daron Lundeen public profile · verified 2026-05-27]. Compliance memberships displayed in the footer include RTA Label, ASACP Approved Member, and SafeLabeling Compliant. TechCrunch coverage in 2017-12 documented Camsoda's early WebRTC streaming adoption, and the 2015 to 2016 VR launch coverage from TechCrunch, Inverse, HuffPost, Fortune, and Android Authority anchored the brand's pioneer-era credibility.

I tested the bracket filter on three evenings with progressively tighter ceilings. The 90-to-120 tokens-per-minute setting surfaced roughly 40 to 60 premium-tier rooms per peak hour. The 30-to-60 setting surfaced 200-plus mid-tier rooms. The UI choice is the strongest budget-discipline argument in the cam category and the reason Camsoda earns the slot despite a smaller premium-tier catalog than LiveJasmin or Chaturbate. Like a price filter on a flight-search engine, except for the per-minute floor on private shows. Once you know what it does, you wonder why every cam platform doesn't ship one.

The catch. Camsoda's payout runs roughly six times less than Chaturbate's, so the brand is rarely the right primary CTA on a broader cam hub. Premium-list framing is the right context. Brand-confusion in the mobile app landscape is real. The iOS App Store listing "Adult Live Video Chat-Camsoda" is published by KA KAO LIVE INC LIMITED, a squatter, and several Android APK files (com.xeijqcga.camsoda, com.camsoda.comdsdoa) are not operated by Secure Live Media. Always direct readers to camsoda.com directly. The AI Recommended sort uses user-history personalization, not synthetic content. This is worth disambiguating explicitly so readers do not assume deepfake involvement.

Try Camsoda Premium →

Honest exclusions, why these 2 platforms didn't qualify

This list includes only platforms that ship HD-mandatory or HD-default streaming, a credible private-show economy with vetted performers, and either a transparent private-show rate disclosure or homepage bracket filter. Two otherwise-strong cam brands in our broader catalog failed that test and were excluded. We name them because a list that hid honest exclusions would not be the list our readers deserve. Most affiliate reviewers in this space don't do this section at all. They publish a top-5, take the commissions, and never explain who didn't make the cut. We do.

Why we left out BongaCams

BongaCams operates a 33-language native UI and a CIS-and-Eastern-European performer roster no Western competitor matches, ranked #3 on CrakRevenue's own Top-5 Cam RevShare Lifetime editorial list for 2025-06. It is a legitimate brand we promote elsewhere, see the general cam ranking and the dedicated our BongaCams full breakdown. It does not qualify for this premium list because the platform does not enforce HD streaming as a default broadcast quality across the roster. Standard rooms ship at 720p or below at standard observation, with HD relegated to a subset of higher-tier performers [Source: BongaCams broadcast quality variance across the live roster · verified 2026-05-27]. Trustpilot signal is also mixed at roughly 3.8 of 5 across 51 reviews, with recurring complaints on unauthorized charges at high token tiers and aggressive pop-ups for free users. Readers who want a multilingual interface with Slavic performer depth should consider BongaCams via the general cam ranking. For premium-specific intent on this list we route to Chaturbate's premium-private mode or LiveJasmin instead.

Why we left out CAM4

CAM4 is one of the older continuously operated freemium cam brands and runs a long-tenured affiliate program. It does not qualify for this premium list because the platform is freemium-first by design. The public free-chat lobby is the primary monetization layer, and the private-show concentration that defines premium architecture is materially lower than LiveJasmin's or Chaturbate's premium-private modes [Source: CAM4 freemium browsing layer and product positioning · verified 2026-05-27]. The performer roster vetting also runs more lightweight than the premium standard we set above. Readers who want freemium-first browsing should consider CAM4 via the general cam ranking or the dedicated best free cam sites list. For premium-specific intent on this list we route to LiveJasmin or Chaturbate's premium-private mode instead.

How we tested

Per our public cam methodology, we walked each platform through the 6-category cam scoring at $0 editorial spend. We captured the homepage navigation, the token or credit purchase modal, the per-minute private rate disclosure on sample rooms, the geo-block messaging, the 2257 page, and the DMCA and Terms of Service pages. Premium-tier room samples were taken at three peak times across US, EU, and APAC evenings. HD streaming was verified by inspecting broadcast resolution metadata where exposed. Ten broadcast rooms (five desktop, five mobile PWA) were stopwatch-tested for time-to-first-frame and re-buffer behavior. Post-purchase reality (billing descriptor on credit-card statements, refund-claim friction, auto-renewal triggers) is scored from aggregated user reports across Trustpilot, SiteJabber, ComplaintsBoard, PissedConsumer, and Reddit, all flagged as "we haven't tested this directly" in the affected category. Full scoring framework, testing protocols, and source-flag policy live at our scoring page.

Frequently asked questions

---

Last verified May 27, 2026 · See errata log for any post-publish corrections · Editor: Alexandra Joly · How our cam scoring works · Editorial process · Affiliate disclosure

Start with our top pick, Chaturbate Premium Private →

Related reading

• Best Live Cam Sites, full category ranking
• Best VR Cam Sites, companion list for headset users
• Best Free Cam Sites, freemium-first counterpart
• Cam Scoring System, methodology
• LiveJasmin full Review
• Jerkmate full Review
• Chaturbate's tipping economy review